Will my charity be independently examined or audited?

Key takeaways

  • Charities in England and Wales with gross income over £40,000 must usually arrange an independent examination or audit.
  • An independent examination is an option for charities with income up to £1.5 million, unless the income and asset thresholds require an audit.
  • A charity must arrange a statutory audit if its gross income exceeds £1.5 million, or if its income exceeds £500,000 and gross assets exceed £5 million.
  • Charities with income of £40,000 or less do not usually need external scrutiny, although other requirements may still apply.
  • Trustees should consider their charity’s finances, risks, governance and funding arrangements when choosing its level of assurance.

 

If you own or manage a charity or social enterprises registered in the UK, it is important to understand whether or not your accounts need to be independently examined or audited. Generally, if your charity's income exceeds £40,000 per annum, an independent examination is required.

However, there are some exceptions and other factors that must be taken into consideration when determining the best course of action for your charity. In this article, we will discuss what you need to know about independent examinations and audits for UK small charities.

 

When does a charity need an independent examination?

Income £40,000 - £1 .5 million

A charity registered in England and Wales will usually need an independent examination or audit when its gross income  exceeds £40,000 but does not exceed £1.5 million

An independent examination provides external scrutiny of a charity’s accounts. The examiner checks whether the accounts agree with the charity’s financial records and comply with relevant accounting requirements.

An independent examination is a separate assurance engagement, not simply a cheaper audit. It has a narrower scope, involves less detailed testing and does not provide an audit opinion on whether the accounts give a true and fair view.

The examiner must meet specific professional qualification requirements if the charity’s gross income exceeds £500,000. Below that threshold, the examiner still needs the skills and practical experience to carry out a competent examination.

A charity may also need an examination or audit below the £40,000 threshold if its governing document or a funding agreement requires one. The Charity Commission can also require an audit in certain circumstances, including suspected misconduct or mismanagement.

 

When is a charity audit required?

Income over £1.5 million

A charity must arrange a statutory audit if its gross income exceeds £1.5 million. It must also arrange one if its gross income exceeds £500,000 and its gross assets exceed £5 million at the end of the financial year. The asset test uses the value of assets before deducting liabilities.

A charity group may also need an audit if it must prepare consolidated accounts. For financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026, the group accounts threshold is total group income above £1.5 million. Each charity in the group must still prepare its own accounts.

An audit involves more extensive work than an independent examination. The auditor gathers evidence and forms an opinion on whether the charity’s financial statements give a true and fair view.

The auditor sets out their opinion in a report that accompanies the charity’s accounts. Only a registered auditor who meets the relevant legal requirements can carry out a statutory audit.

Some charitable companies must also arrange an audit under the Companies Act 2006, even if they do not meet the charity audit thresholds.

 

What is the difference between an independent examination and an audit?

An independent examination and an audit both provide external scrutiny of a charity’s accounts, but they differ in scope, depth and assurance. The right option depends on the charity’s income, assets, complexity, governance needs and stakeholder expectations.

 

Independent Examination vs Charity Audit

Feature Independent examination Audit
When it is generally required Gross income over £40,000 and up to £1.5 million, unless an audit is required or chosen Gross income over £1.5 million, or over £500,000 with gross assets over £5 million
Level of assurance Limited assurance that the accounts appear consistent with the underlying records Higher assurance, supported by audit evidence
Scope Review of whether the accounts appear consistent with the charity’s financial records Detailed examination of financial statements, transactions, balances, disclosures and estimates
Fraud and risk assessment Limited procedures compared with an audit More extensive risk assessment, including fraud risks
Internal controls and governance Limited review More extensive review of relevant controls and governance
Professional qualification Examiner must meet professional qualification requirements when income exceeds £500,000 A registered auditor must carry out the audit
Report Independent examiner’s report accompanies the accounts Auditor’s report accompanies the accounts
Typical suitability Smaller or less complex charities with straightforward finances Larger or more complex charities, including those with significant assets, trading activity or subsidiaries
Cost and administration Usually lower cost and less time-consuming Usually higher cost and more time-consuming

 

When can a charity avoid an independent examination or audit?

If your charity has an income of £40,000 or less, it will not usually require an independent examination or audit.

However, external scrutiny is sometimes required of charities with gross incomes below £40,000. Although not legally mandatory, the charity’s governing document may require an independent examination or an audit to be performed, or this may be requested by the Board of Trustees. An audit examination may also be required by a grant-making body or by the Charity Commission.

Charities in England and Wales must also meet these reporting requirements:

  • Annual accounts: All charities must prepare accounts and provide them to the public on request.
  • Trustees’ annual report: All registered charities must prepare a trustees’ annual report and provide it to the public.
  • Annual return: Registered charities with income over £10,000 must submit an annual return to the Charity Commission.
  • Filing accounts: Registered charities with income over £25,000 must send their annual report and accounts to the Charity Commission.
  • Governing documents: A charity’s constitution, trust deed or articles of association may require an independent examination or audit.
  • Funding agreements: Grant-makers, lenders and local authorities may set their own external scrutiny requirements.

Charitable organisations are accountable to their donors or the people they help, and their exposure to risk grows as they become better-known and more successful. The requirement for an audit or independent examination does not imply wrongdoing, poor management, or lack of transparency – rather, it provides donors with the accountability and credibility required to maintain trust in the sector, comply with charity law and best practice, and reassure donors that their contributions are being used effectively.

 

Is an independent examination the same as an audit?

No. An independent examination has a narrower scope and provides less assurance than an audit. It checks whether the accounts appear consistent with the charity’s records. An audit involves more extensive testing and an independent opinion on the financial statements.

 

Do charities with income below £40,000 need any external scrutiny?

Not usually, under the new thresholds for England and Wales. However, a charity’s governing document, a funder or the Charity Commission may still require an independent examination or audit. Trustees should also consider whether voluntary scrutiny would strengthen their governance.

 

Can a charity choose a voluntary audit?

Yes. A charity can commission a voluntary audit even if it does not meet the statutory audit thresholds. This may suit an organisation with complex finances, significant funding arrangements or stakeholders who expect greater assurance.

 

The bottom line

The new thresholds give many charities in England and Wales more choice over the need for an independent examination or audit. Charities with income of £40,000 or less will not usually need either, while larger organisations must consider the income and asset tests.

Trustees should not remove external scrutiny simply because the legal threshold has changed. The right approach depends on the charity’s finances, complexity, risks, governance needs and stakeholder expectations. Weigh the cost of additional assurance against the confidence it gives funders, donors and the wider charity.

 

How can David Howard support your charity’s accounts?

Our experienced team of charity accountants can handle all your general accounting and auditing needs, including payroll, bookkeeping, and tailored advice for charities and flat management companies.

For more information about auditing and accounting for charities, please get in touch with David Howard today

Image by senivpetro on Freepik

Subscribe